一般审稿意见至少要包含三条 一般审稿看法至少要包含三条： （1）简要描述论文的探讨内容和意义，并作出评价对于其比较好的部分，要给于确定 （2）针对文章中的内容和结果，指出其详细的不足之处，并谈谈你的看法文章的不足之处有三种层次：第一，论文结果不正确或有重大失误；其次，论文缺乏重要的结果；第三，论文的结果不够完善 （3）最终，给出你的综合评价，接受，修改，还是拒收 英文论文审稿看法汇总 以下关于英文投稿过程中编辑给出的看法,与大家一起共享12点无轻重主次之分每一点内容由总结性标题和代表性审稿人看法构成 1、目标和结果不清楚 It is noted that your manuscript needs careful editing by someone with expertise in technical English editing paying particular attention to English grammar, spelling, and sentence structure so that the goals and results of the study are clear to the reader. 2、未说明探讨方法或说明不充分。
◆ In general, there is a lack of explanation of replicates and statistical me thods used in the study. ◆ Furthermore, an explanation of why the authors did these various experiments should be provided. 3、对于探讨设计的rationale: Also, there are few explanations of the rationale for the study design. 4、夸张地陈述结论/夸大成果/不严谨： The conclusions are overstated.For example, the study did not show if the side effects from initial copper burst can be avoid with the polymer formulation. 5、对hypothesis的清楚界定： A hypothesis needs to be presented。
6、对某个概念或工具运用的rationale/定义概念： What was the rationale for the film/SBF volume ratio? 7、对探讨问题的定义： Try to set the problem discued in this paper in more clear, write one section to define the problem 8、如何凸现原创性以及如何充分地写literature review: Thetopicisnovelbuttheapplicationproposedisnotsonovel. 9、对claim,如A＞B的证明，verification: There is no experimental comparison of the algorithm with previously known work, so it is impoible to judge whether the algorithm is an improvement on previous work. 10、严谨度问题： MNQ is easier than the primitive PNQS, how to prove that. 11、格式（重视程度）： ◆ In addition, the list of references is not in our style.It is close but not completely correct.I have attached a pdf file with \"Instructions for Authors\" which shows examples. ◆ Before submitting a revision be sure that your material is properly prepared and formatted.If you are unsure, please consult the formatting nstructions to authors that are given under the \"Instructions and Forms\" button in he upper right-hand corner of the screen. 12、语言问题（出现最多的问题）： 有关语言的审稿人看法： ◆ It is noted that your manuscript needs careful editing by someone with expertise in technical English editing paying particular attention to English grammar, spelling, and sentence structure so that the goals and results of the study are clear to the reader. ◆ The authors must have their work reviewed by a proper translation/reviewing service before submiion; only then can a proper review be performed.Most sentences contain grammatical and/or spelling mistakes or are not complete sentences. ◆ As presented, the writing is not acceptable for the journal.There are pro blems with sentence structure, verb tense, and clause construction. ◆ The English of your manuscript must be improved before resubmiion.We str ongly suggest that you obtain aistance from a colleague who is well-versed i n English or whose native language is English. ◆ Please have someone competent in the English language and the subject matte r of your paper go over the paper and correct it.? ◆ the quality of English needs improving. 来自编辑的激励： Encouragement from reviewers: ◆ I would be very glad to re-review the paper in greater depth once it has be en edited because the subject is interesting. ◆ There is continued interest in your manuscript titled \"……\" which you subm itted to the Journal of Biomedical Materials Research: Part B - Applied Biomat erials. ◆ The Submiion has been greatly improved and is worthy of publication. 一般审稿看法至少要包含三条 作文提纲一般包含 学理发一般要学多久 一般民用建筑包含的方案有哪些？ 人际交往九条一般原则 基层国税领导要关爱一般干部 追求卓越 老师要学会用三条腿走路（举荐） 工程整体竣工报告一般都包含哪几项内容 学期教学安排一般应包含以下内容 出售时间之前你要牢记的三条 铁律(下) 本文来源：网络收集与整理，如有侵权，请联系作者删除，谢谢！第7页 共7页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页第 7 页 共 7 页。