《发表paper的捷径》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《发表paper的捷径（42页珍藏版）》请在金锄头文库上搜索。
1、推销的艺术A small personal perspectives on Doing Research and Writing Papers达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915AgendaPaper是什么?如何衡量一篇paper的分量Paper的主要构成How to work out solid papers?达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915Paper是什么Paper是Research的成果科研内容的载体科研成果的体现与其他研
2、究人员交流的主要方式research的目标是什么推动科学进步促进人类社会的发展进步达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915Research的规律(1)From Zhihua Zhou, 2001达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915Research的规律(2)Research分类现实版科幻版(硬科幻、软科幻)玄幻版(无极)Research Domain科研的圈子有大有小， 庙宇香火有旺有衰Network=这是最好的时代，也是最坏的时代达
3、晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915“Measure“ of good research Good research is hard to plan or measure!PapersReputation of conferences/journalsCitationsDemos/prototypes/systemsEconomical/social impact达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915认识Paper的规律(1)-分类Jou
4、rnal Paper重视理论研究强调完备性Conference Paper重视新的理论、新的实验方法、新产品等强调创新性我们的主要目标达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915Writing a good paper is difficult达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915A paper is a FilmA paper is similar with a filmpresentation为了一篇好paper，你必须成为：一个好的编剧
5、一个好的演员一个好的化妆师etc.How to do these things?达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915如何做好paper?Reading Good Papers向高手学习掌握paper的正确阅读方法Do a tough work游而击之深思熟虑Good Prepartion文章必须让观众眼前一亮有意识瞄准，无意识击发认清观众，瞄准会议达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915如何做好paper?Whats a good pa
6、per?New Conceptions? 量子计算？New transplanting? New little Improvements?Contributions转换视角Not from a user/reader.Not only from a reviewer, but for an author达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915从Reviewer的角度出发OverallContributionMotivation得有好的剧本Shinning Points经典情节Tough & solid work有根有
7、据，要有细致的分析Structure有前有后，像模像样达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915从author的角度出发What makes a good paper?How to find good problems?What makes a bad paper?How to write a good paper?Writing skillsHow to get your paper been accepted?Solid work & relationships达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j
8、 i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915What makes a good paper?ContentsOriginalityResultsContributionsWriting skillsOrganizationPresentationWordingHaving high standard for both!达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915ContentsWell-motivated, interesting problemWith real-world applications
9、 or theoretical valuesChallenging issuesWorthy to be investigatedGood ideas and approachTechnically sound?Significant resultsExtensive & intensive analysis and evaluationAssessment of strengths and limitationsReference to appropriate related work“This is a very solid paper.”达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a
10、 j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915What makes a good paper?Measurements of motivationImportant,MeaningfulchallengingSignificant and interesting problemClear statement/formulation of the problemWhy it is interesting/important, always back up with real apps/systemsWhy existing solutions cant work拍脑袋的id
11、ea,要不得Problem Size一篇文章能解决的问题是有限的集中到点才能发力研究需要逐步进行No Perfect work十全十美的事，让人怀疑这个问题是否值得研究一下子就解决光的问题，往往可研究性存疑研究需要有一定的可持续性达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915What makes a good paperInteresting solutionsSimple but elegantIn-depth analysis, good theoretical resultsNew system design/imp
12、lementation methodologySolid performance evaluationImpl and evaluation on real testbedsThorough realistic simulations达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915What makes a bad/average paperOld problems“yet another routing protocol“ “we improve an existing solution by 20%“Shaky assum
13、ptionsMade in favor of your solutions Complicated your problemsAverage solutionsCentralized solutions without good bounds Heuristics without insightsQuestionable performance evaluationNo comparisons with existing solutions No reasonable explanation to unexpected resultsNever throw away bad data and
14、only show good ones! Ignorance of important issuespacket loss, interference, perfect sensing, change 10 parameters in a run Lack of enough details: “implemented it in NS2, and here are results“.Which version of NS2? What wireless prop. model? Energy model?达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o
15、 mQQ:1191268915Find a research problem - DosGetting familiar with “real stuff“Whatre real apps of sensor nets? Whatre the limitations of practical sensor nets? Whatre the unique properties of sensor nets?Paper readingGeneral vs. special topics Are the fundamental assumptions challenged?Circular sens
16、ing/comm. modelsRandom mobilitySystem or theory?System work: focuses more on impls & evaluation, simple (but non-trivial) ideas Theoretical work: deep solution and analysis of interesting problems Problem driven, works for me, but not the only way达 晋 医 学 编 译E-m a i l :d a j i n 2011q q .c o mQQ:1191268915Find a resea
